ProcurementSecurityVendor Management

Vendor Due Diligence: Questions to Ask CRM and AI Providers Before You Sign

bbudge

2026-02-10

11 min read

A 2026 procurement checklist for operations teams: security, data portability, AI risk, integrations and pricing questions to ask CRM and AI vendors.

Vendor Due Diligence: Questions to Ask CRM and AI Providers Before You Sign

Hook: If your finance and operations teams are still reconciling CRM exports in spreadsheets, guessing subscription spend, or worrying whether an AI assistant is training on customer data — you need a procurement checklist built for 2026. With AI becoming baked into CRMs and regulators sharpening focus in late 2025, asking the right vendor questions up front saves time, prevents costly migrations, and stops data leakage.

Why this matters now (short answer)

In early 2026 the landscape has two clear realities: first, CRMs increasingly embed AI features (recommendations, summarization, synthesis) that change how customer data is used; second, pricing models are shifting to mixed seat + usage (tokens, API calls) which can create runaway costs. Procurement teams and small business owners must verify security, portability, integration and pricing before signing to avoid surprises that directly hit cash flow and operational headcount.

High-level checklist: What you must validate before a signature

Use this quick checklist during vendor selection to prioritize demos, legal review and technical PoCs:

Security & compliance: third-party certifications, encryption, incident response SLAs
Data portability & exit: full export formats, timeframe, escrow, cost of export
Integration & interoperability: API capabilities, webhooks, IdP, SCIM, connector roadmap
AI vendor risk: model provenance, training data policies, red-team testing
Pricing & contract terms: metering, overages, trial limits, license rights

Security & compliance questions (and what good answers look like)

Security is non-negotiable. Below are focused questions — and the responses you should expect from a vendor that understands enterprise procurement.

1. Certifications & audits

Question: Which certifications do you maintain (SOC 2 Type II, ISO 27001, PCI-DSS, HIPAA)?
Why it matters: Certifications indicate regular, external validation of controls. For small businesses that handle payments or PHI, specific attestations are critical.
Good answer: Vendor provides recent SOC 2 Type II and ISO 27001 reports under NDA and has a compliance roadmap for any missing attestations.

2. Encryption & key management

Question: Is data encrypted at rest and in transit? Do you offer customer-managed keys (CMK) or bring-your-own-key (BYOK)?
Why it matters: Encryption protects data during storage and movement; CMKs reduce vendor lock-in and increase control.
Good answer: AES-256 at rest, TLS 1.2+ in transit, and CMK support via KMS (AWS, Azure, GCP).

3. Identity, access control & least privilege

Question: What IAM features do you support — SSO (SAML/OIDC), SCIM for user provisioning, role-based access control (RBAC), and audit logs?
Why it matters: Tight IAM prevents privilege creep and supports offboarding.
Good answer: Native SSO with SAML/OIDC, SCIM for automated provisioning and deprovisioning, granular RBAC, and immutable audit logs available via API.

4. Incident response & breach notification

Question: What is your incident response SLA and notification timeline? Will you provide root cause analysis and remediation plans?
Why it matters: Fast detection and transparent communication limit business disruption and compliance penalties.
Good answer: 24/7 monitoring with defined MTTD/MTTR metrics, initial notification within 24–72 hours, and a commitment to provide a post-incident report.

Data portability & exit strategy — ask these before committing

Portability is the single best insurance policy for procurement teams. Vendors may promise “easy exports” — validate specifics.

5. Export formats, scope, and turnaround

Question: What data export formats are available (CSV, JSON, SQL dump)? How long does a full export take and is there a cost?
Why it matters: You need usable data formats for migration to a new system or in-house analytics.
Good answer: Full exports in CSV/JSON and database-compatible formats within 7 business days by default; expedited export options for an agreed fee; sample export during PoC.

6. Partial exports & incremental sync

Question: Do you support incremental exports or CDC-style change feeds for ongoing replication?
Why it matters: Incremental sync reduces migration downtime and is essential for hybrid workflows.
Good answer: Streamable webhooks, CDC endpoints, or integrations with ETL providers for continuous replication.

7. Deletion, retention & proof of removal

Question: What is your data retention policy and process for deletion? Will you provide certification that customer data has been deleted from backups and logs?
Why it matters: Regulatory compliance and customer trust require verifiable deletion processes.
Good answer: Clear retention windows, deletion triggered on request with confirmation within 30 days, and written attestation for removal from backups and logs where feasible.

AI-specific vendor risk questions

AI introduces new dimensions of vendor risk: model training, data reuse, hallucinations, and explainability. Ask these questions to quantify risk.

8. Model training & data usage

Question: Do you use customer data to train models? If yes, is it identifiable and can we opt out?
Why it matters: Using customer data to improve models can create IP and privacy concerns; opt-out is often a hard requirement.
Good answer: Clear policy—customer data is not used to train shared models without explicit consent. Option for dedicated/isolated models or on-prem/private deployments.

9. Provenance, hallucinations & guardrails

Question: How do you track model provenance and mitigate hallucinations? Do you offer explainability tools and human-in-the-loop safeguards?
Why it matters: Outputs from AI may be inaccurate; provenance and red-team test results help you evaluate reliability.
Good answer: Versioned models with documented training datasets (or clear denials of customer data usage), deterministic logs of AI outputs, confidence scores, and configurable guardrails or human review workflows.

10. Red-teaming, bias testing & third-party audits

Question: Do you perform adversarial testing, bias assessments, and third-party model audits? Are results available under NDA?
Why it matters: Demonstrates proactive risk management and supports compliance in regulated industries.
Good answer: Regular red-team exercises, bias testing reports, and willingness to share summaries with customers under NDA.

"Weak data management remains the biggest blocker to scaling AI across enterprises," — organizations like Salesforce and industry research in late 2025 reinforced this trend. Ask hard questions about where your customer data actually flows.

Integration & operational fit

Operational buyers need to know whether the CRM will slot into existing tech stacks without manual workarounds.

11. API completeness & rate limits

Question: Do your APIs cover all critical objects (contacts, leads, activities, custom fields)? What are default rate limits and tiered options?
Why it matters: Partial APIs force fragile scraping or manual exports.
Good answer: Full REST/Graph APIs for core objects, reasonable default rate limits, and negotiable higher tiers for mission-critical integrations.

12. Native connectors & middleware

Question: Which native connectors exist (ERP, billing, accounting, marketing automation) and do you partner with major iPaaS providers?
Why it matters: Native connectors speed deployment; iPaaS compatibility future-proofs integrations.
Good answer: Out-of-the-box connectors for major platforms plus clear documentation for SMTP, webhooks, and iPaaS partners (Workato, Zapier, Mulesoft).

13. Identity & provisioning

Question: Is SSO available in all tiers? Do you support SCIM for automated user lifecycle management?
Why it matters: Manual user management creates security gaps and administrative overhead.
Good answer: SSO and SCIM available in standard enterprise plans and documented mapping for role sync.

Pricing, metering & contract clauses to negotiate

Pricing surprises are among the top causes of post-signature regret. Ask these pricing and contract-level questions and capture commitments in the contract.

14. Pricing model clarity

Question: Is pricing seat-based, usage-based, or hybrid? How are AI tokens, API calls, and ingestion measured?
Why it matters: Usage-based components can spike unexpectedly; you should model expected usage before commit.
Good answer: Transparent metering definitions, a clear pricing calculator, and caps or pre-bought packages for usage spikes.

15. Overage caps & notification

Question: Can we set hard caps or receive alerts before overage charges apply? What is the billing cadence for overages?
Why it matters: Limits protect budgets and force conversations before costs escalate.
Good answer: Customer-configurable caps and multi-channel alerts; no surprise overages without prior written approval for amounts above a threshold.

16. Contractual protections to include

Negotiate these contract clauses into your MSA or SOW:

Data Portability Clause: Vendor must provide full export in agreed formats within X business days at no additional cost.
Data Deletion & Certification: Vendor will delete customer data upon termination and provide written attestation within 30 days.
Security SLAs & Penalties: Define MTTD/MTTR, incident notification timelines (24–72 hours), and service credits for security SLA failures.
Audit Rights: Right to conduct or receive third-party audit reports annually under NDA.
Model Use & IP: Clarify that customer data is not used to train shared models unless explicitly permitted and compensated.
Price Escalation Limits: Caps on annual price increases and notice periods for changes to pricing or metering.

Practical procurement playbook: step-by-step

Here’s a compact operating plan procurement and operations can follow during selection and negotiation.

Run a 2-week technical PoC — include a full export test, API throughput test and a simulated incident (communication drill) to validate response times.
Request compliance artifacts — SOC 2, penetration test reports, and red-team summaries under NDA.
Model-risk review — ask for AI model provenance, training data policies, and a summary of mitigation controls for hallucinations and bias.
Get legal to draft key clauses — include data portability, deletion certification, audit rights and price protection clauses in the MSA.
Negotiate caps and alerts — ensure overage protection and billing alerts are documented in the SOW.
Plan your exit now — schedule a quarterly export and validate it. Build a tested migration runbook before go-live.

Case study (operations-focused)

Here’s an anonymized example from a small professional services firm that leveraged this checklist in late 2025:

The firm needed a CRM with AI-based proposal drafting. During procurement they discovered the shortlisted vendor used customer inputs to fine-tune shared models. Using our checklist they negotiated an isolated model instance and a firm clause preventing training on customer data. They also required a 7-day full export during PoC and a monthly export cadence post-implementation. The result: predictable AI costs, no surprise IP exposure, and a migration-ready data set that reduced future replatforming costs by an estimated 80%.

Advanced strategies for 2026 and beyond

As we move further into 2026, expect these vendor trends — and use them to your advantage during procurement:

Private / dedicated model deployments: Vendors increasingly offer isolated or on-prem AI deployments for customers with stringent data requirements. Ask about private-cloud or edge options.
Observable AI: Demand model observability — lineage, inference logs, and feature-level explainability — so you can audit decisions and tune guardrails.
Usage forecasting tools: Leverage vendor-provided usage simulators and your own synthetic tests to model token/API spend over six- and twelve-month horizons. See tools for building operational dashboards and usage forecasts.
Data clean room support: For complex integrations, insist on secure data clean rooms or privacy-preserving analytics to share insights without exposing raw data.

Red flags that should stop a deal

Walk away or pause negotiations if you encounter these:

No ability to export full records in a usable format without developer intervention.
Vendor refuses to commit that customer data won't be used to train shared models, and can't offer isolation.
Lack of third-party attestations or refusal to share pen-test summaries under NDA.
Opaque metering definitions or unwillingness to offer caps/alerts for usage-based fees.
No clear incident response timeline or refusal to commit to notification windows in the contract.

Quick templates: questions to copy into your RFP

Copy-paste these into your RFP or vendor questionnaire.

Provide a copy of your most recent SOC 2 Type II and penetration test summary (NDA acceptable).
Do you use customer data to train or tune any models? If yes, explain how and offer an opt-out mechanism.
Describe your data export capabilities: formats, time to complete a full export, and associated costs.
Confirm support for SAML/OIDC SSO and SCIM-based user provisioning.
Detail your incident response process and maximum notification SLA for confirmed breaches.
Provide a price calculator for typical usage patterns and define how overages are billed and notified.

Actionable takeaways

Never assume “export” equals usable data — test it during your PoC.
Lock AI training and model-use commitments into contract language.
Negotiate overage protections and require billing alerts to protect budgets.
Demand audit artifacts and pen-test summaries under NDA before go-live.
Plan your exit from day one: monthly exports and a tested migration runbook are cheap insurance.

Final thought

Procurement of CRM and AI vendors in 2026 is no longer just about features — it’s about operational resilience, data control, and predictable costs. Vendors who can demonstrate strong security posture, clear portability, robust integrations, and transparent pricing will be your partners; the others will be an ongoing operational drag.

Call to action: Use this checklist in your next RFP and run a focused 2-week technical PoC that includes a full export and an incident communication drill. If you’d like a ready-to-use RFP template and contract clause bank tailored to your industry, request our procurement toolkit and get a migration runbook template you can use in under an hour.

budge

Contributor

Senior editor and content strategist. Writing about technology, design, and the future of digital media. Follow along for deep dives into the industry's moving parts.